Is Rye Flour Good For You? A Scientist Explains

Rye (Secale cereale) is a grass grain that has been grown and used as food from Neolithic times in Asia, having since spread, like wheat, barley and other grains, all over Europe. It has been traditionally consumed as food made with its flour (such as bread), fermented items (like spirits and probiotics), animal fodder or just cooked as whole grains.

Like most grains before it, rye became one of the wonder-foods of the past decades, allegedly capable of fighting insulin resistance, controlling appetite and promoting weight loss, decreasing inflammation and many other benefits.

Rye flour is what it says: flour made from rye grains.

Does rye flour offer all the benefits attributed to it? Yes, it does, not unlike other whole grain flours. Each one of the grain flours offers a higher or lower benefit in one of those health issues. They all do so not because there is something magical on the grain itself, but because it is whole grain instead of refined flours, as most industrialized starchy foods are made of.

Observe the picture below:

rye flour

From: Oldway Whole Grains Counsel, “Whole grains: an important source of essential nutrients”.

Consensus among the medical and nutrition sciences communities about the importance of higher fiber consumption and whole grain consumption is not recent (21, 20, 10). Whole grain products (flour, bread, pasta, etc) are made from flour that pulverizes the grain itself, including the endosperm, the bran and the germ.

This is a whole grain:

A wheat kernel and its nutritional value. Data sources Illustration and composition of wheat kernel is based on (and simplified from) Berghoff (1998), cited by muehlenchemie, as well as other sources on the internet. Nutritional value: Endosperm Germ Bran Berghoff W, 1998. Längsschnitt durch ein Getreidekorn. aid infodienst Verbraucherschutz Ernährung, Bonn. By Jkwchui – Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0,

Regardless of the type of diet that is best for you – your metabolism, your intolerances, your genetic makeup, etc –, what concerns both the medical community and evolutionary biologists is that humans have been consuming grains for at least a good 10 thousand years, but only refining them for the last 100 years. When grains are refined, most of the bran and germ are eliminated.

The refined product is mostly the starchy endosperm (21). In the grain-refining process the bran and germ are removed, resulting in the loss of dietary fiber, vitamins, minerals, lignans, phyto-oestrogens, phenolic compounds, and phytic acid. These are all compounds that have been associated with positive biological activity.

This has become such an important problem that medical and dietetics societies, as well as government health agencies, have been issuing statements encouraging the population to eat more fiber (23). They recommend the consumption of whole grains to prevent chronic diseases. Epidemiologic studies suggest that whole grains are protective against cancer, especially gastrointestinal cancers such as gastric and colon cancer, and cardiovascular disease.

The benefits derived from consuming whole grains are not just the preservation of the fibrous part, but also compounds with anti-oxidant activity such as trace minerals, phenolic compounds, and phytoestrogens, with potential hormonal action. Other potential mechanisms include binding of carcinogens and modulation of the glycemic response. (10).

Rye flour and rye consumption in general has been shown to be beneficial. Also, each grain is slightly different in its composition and, therefore, in its biological properties. These different properties will be discussed in the items below.

Is there any research?

As the graph from the “Whole Grains Council” shows, most whole grains studied up to now show important benefits to human health.

Research into rye, specifically, is not particularly new. As the sequence of graphics below demonstrate, the interest on rye was almost constant during the past 70 years. Constant and small. The research into specific aspects of rye’s biological activity did peak in recent times. However, as is suggested by the sequence of images, this interest reflects much more a general interest in the importance of whole grains than on any special power rye may have.

Research containing the word “rye” in the publication title retrieved from Medline. This graphs the documents matching the query, divided by the total number of publications per year and corrects for the increasing number of publications (Palidwor et al 2010).

Research containing the word “rye” AND the word “cancer” in the publication title retrieved from Medline. This graphs the documents matching the query, divided by the total number of publications per year and corrects for the increasing number of publications (Palidwor et al 2010).

Research containing the word “oat” AND the word “cancer” in the publication title retrieved from Medline. This graphs the documents matching the query, divided by the total number of publications per year and corrects for the increasing number of publications (Palidwor et al 2010).

Research containing the word “wheat” AND the word “cancer” in the publication title retrieved from Medline. This graphs the documents matching the query, divided by the total number of publications per year and corrects for the increasing number of publications (Palidwor et al 2010).

Research containing the word “fiber” AND the word “cancer” in the publication title retrieved from Medline. This graphs the documents matching the query, divided by the total number of publications per year and corrects for the increasing number of publications (Palidwor et al 2010).

Recent research on rye has been published on reputable peer reviewed journals (11, 12). However, for reasons not hard to understand, they are mostly comparisons of whole grain rye with refined wheat (18, 7).

Considering methods and outlet, it is not bad research. However, it is not a sufficiently strong basis to promote rye as such a special grain in comparison to other whole grain foods.

Will rye flour promote weight loss?

There is no doubt that the substitution of refined grains by whole grains can help with weight loss. One of the most important factors in this effect is the presence of “resistant starch”. Starch is a long chain of glucose molecules. If it is fully broken down into its monosaccharide units (glucose), all its energy is available.

However, if a part of the starch in your food can’t be broken down, in practice you ingest less energy. What happens to resistant starch in your body? You don’t digest it, but your friendly gut bacteria do. For the good and for the bad: their metabolism can release useful products, such as short chain fatty-acids, but they can also cause digestive discomfort (14, 5, 15).

Some examples of resistant starch composition in whole grains are pearl barley (cooked), with 3.2g/cup, lentils (cooked), with 5.0g/cup or quinoa (cooked), with 2.0g/cup. Rye is reported to have a resistant starch content of 2.6-3.5%. Cooking, baking or freezing food changes their resistant starch composition (24).

Whether rye is more helpful than any other whole grain flours or preparations for weight loss, we can’t say.

Will it help control appetite?

There is ample published evidence that rye products produce prolonged satiety. But compared to what? The published studies point out that there is accumulated evidence that more fibrous meals are associated with appetite control (as are fattier meals). The emphasis on rye is that it hadn’t been studied for this effect as much as oats, whole wheat and other whole grains (8, 6, 25)

Will rye products help you control your appetite? Yes, they will. And so will many other whole grains. The mechanism, again, is related to the different digestive processes that take place on foods containing whole grains compared to refined grains, not only because of the presence of fibers, resistant starches but other components as well as gut microbiota activity.

Will it “regulate glucose”? What about “gene regulation” and inflammation?

Here we need to stop and introduce a few more scientific enigmas, as well as some certainties. Also, we need to dissect the study mentioned by the proponents of the claims concerning glucose, insulin and gene regulation as well as inflammation modulation.

First of all, let’s clarify that these three issues are all interrelated: insulin and glucose regulation, gene regulation and inflammation (11, 12).

Metabolic syndrome is a set of conditions that usually leads to type 2 diabetes and/or cardiovascular disease. These conditions are: abdominal obesity, high blood glucose levels, high blood pressure, high serum triglycerides and low high density lipoprotein levels. It is a snowball of metabolic disasters that includes dysfunctional insulin response (insulin resistance, but also post-prandial – which means after having a meal – hyperinsulinemia, etc).

In one study (12), 47 people who already had metabolic syndrome were the experimental subjects of a 12 week diet intervention consisting of:

GROUP 1: consumed oat and wheat bread and potato (this is the high postprandial insulin response group, which is bad and related to the worst outcomes of the syndrome)

GROUP 2: consumed rye bread and pasta (this is the low postprandial insulin response group, which is good and goes the other way)

Several biochemical measurements were made after the completion of the experimental period, including plasma glucose, serum insulin, plasma free fatty acids, adrenaline, noradrenaline, and several inflammatory mediators (Plasma cytokines, tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α), interleukin (IL)-1β, IL-6, and IL-10).

What this study showed was that GROUP 1 had higher inflammatory mediators, higher insulin response and slower glucose response (decrease after meals). To make things worse, the genes responsible for this bad outcome were increased in function (“up-regulated”). In other words, this group was in bad shape as compared to GROUP 2.

Considering that the relationship between diabetes, its related degenerative conditions, and inflammation is consensual today (19, 2, 28), it looks like low post-prandial insulin response is relevant. Does that mean rye is essential? No. It means exactly what it says: low post-prandial insulin response is important. Does rye promote that? Yes. And so do innumerable other dietetic alternatives, including radical reduction of carbohydrates in general.

Let us examine the takeaways here:

Publication claim What it means
“Long-term intake of cereal foods with differing postprandial insulin responses may be a factor that modulates the inflammatory status in individuals with the metabolic syndrome” The type of cereal food you eat matters. Some will increase inflammation (bad) and others will not (good).
“Diets with a low glycemic index and load or high in whole grains have been associated with decreased concentrations of inflammation markers” The more and the faster the food you eat is absorbed as glucose, the worst it is for you. The less and the slower it does, the less inflammation it causes, the better it is for you.
“Low-grade inflammation has been implicated in obesity and in the development of comorbidities, such as the metabolic syndrome, T2DM (type 2 diabetes mellitus), and cardiovascular disease” All these bad metabolic conditions and their outcomes, such as cardiovascular disease, renal disorders, etc, are associated with inflammation.
“Whole-grain diets with a low glycemic index probably decrease the risk of T2DM through improved insulin resistance and β cell function, but modulation of inflammation may be another mechanism” Whole grains protect you from diabetes and its related disorders through many mechanisms and one of them may be decreased inflammation.
“Repeated postprandial hyperinsulinemia and early postprandial hyperglycemia may cause insulin resistance, β cell dysfunction, and inflammation” If you keep eating a lot of high glycemic index foods, such as candies, cookies, etc, you will promote all the bad things that may end up in diabetes.
“The mechanisms by which the oat and wheat bread and potato diet can induce metabolic stress and immune activation are unclear” We have no idea why oat, wheat and potato had such a bad response.
“We detected a significant difference in IL-10 receptor α (IL-10Rα) mRNA expression between the groups. The oat and wheat bread and potato diet up-regulated the mRNA expression of IL-10Rα 1.4-fold (P < 0.001, within group change), whereas with rye bread and pasta diet expression was suppressed (P = 0.002, between-group change).” Everything that happens in the body, including metabolic responses, is controlled by genes. The genes that control the expression of inflammatory response were significantly more active in GROUP 1.

Will it help with gallstones?

There are several studies that strongly suggest a gallstone suppressing or protective effect of rye as compared to other grains, and all whole grains as compared to fiber-free diets. All these studies were conducted on hamsters (26, 27).

As for humans, we really don’t know a lot. Studies (and office practice) suggests that rapid weight loss is a factor in the development of symptomatic gallstones (9), but also, surprisingly, vegetarian diets (16). A more comprehensive study correlated a “healthier” diet (more fiber, olive oil, fish, less refined sugars) with less incidence of symptomatic gallstones (3).

Does It Have Anti-Cancer Properties?

Apparently, it does. There are several studies associating rye consumption to lower cancer incidence in the line already pointed out here that relates whole grains to cancer preventive effects. However, there are some studies associating specific components of rye to anti-cancer biological activity.

For example, an in vitro study on the prostate-cancer suppressor activity of benzoxazinoids, which naturally occur in high concentration in rye, encourages more research on the matter (22), especially considering the accumulated evidence of the positive effects of whole grain rye consumption on the evolution of prostate cancer in elderly men (4).

Other studies on bioactive compounds and the generic benefits of whole grains show positive results on colorectal (13) and breast cancer (1). They do use rye in the study, but the bioactive compounds or properties are not specific to it.

Here is the take away: nutrition and cancer researchers have known for a long time that there is a correlation between higher fiber consumption in food and lower cancer incidence. This is, however, an epidemiological information. That means that when we look at big data, we see a trend. That does not mean that we can predict any outcome on any specific individual. What should you do, then? It sounds like a good idea to keep a diet with higher fiber content and, especially if you have been diagnosed with prostate cancer, rye is a good choice.

But as we emphasize here all the time, this is a rational, evidence-based decision about doing the best you can to prevent or manage your condition. It doesn’t mean rye will cause anything that will cure your cancer. We don’t know that, and we won’t know it for a very long time.

Is rye flour safe?

Rye contains gluten. Unless you have some form of gluten intolerance (or its more serious manifestation, celiac disease), rye flour is safe. Of course, the reaction of your friendly gut bacteria to it is unpredictable. You can feel great or you can feel some bowel discomfort.

You may also feel discomfort only at certain frequency or quantity consumption. This is not specific to rye: we are pretty unique when it comes to how we metabolize food.

Conclusion

According to the present review of published scientific evidence, there is no indication that rye flour consumption can predictably make an important difference in quality of life, providing great benefits. For a healthy individual, it may or may not: again, biological individuality is king when it comes to how we metabolize food.

We are not thinking about obese or overweight people, or those making the transition from very unhealthy diets, highly dense in refined sugars and trans fatty acids, to a healthier lifestyle. For those, rye (or any other whole grain) will be wonder-food. Just like any exercise, even just walking, may be wonder-move for inactive people.

Anyway, educate yourself on the benefits of whole grains and their importance in your meals. It is much more than just avoiding constipation (10).

References

  1. Adlercreutz, Herman. “Can rye intake decrease risk of human breast cancer?.” Food & nutrition research 54, no. 1 (2010): 5231. http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.3402/fnr.v54i0.5231
  2. Agrawal, Neeraj Kumar, and Saket Kant. “Targeting inflammation in diabetes: Newer therapeutic options.” World journal of diabetes5, no. 5 (2014): 697. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4138593/
  3. Di Ciaula, A., G. Garruti, G. Frühbeck, M. De Angelis, O. De Bari, F. Lammert, and P. Portincasa. “The Role Of Diet In The Pathogenesis Of Cholesterol Gallstones.” Current medicinal chemistry (2017). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/28554328
  4. Eriksen, Anne Kirstine, Rikke Dalgaard Hansen, Michael Borre, Ryan Godsk Larsen, Jeppe Munthe Jensen, Kristian Overgaard, Mette Borre et al. “A lifestyle intervention among elderly men on active surveillance for non-aggressive prostate cancer: a randomised feasibility study with whole-grain rye and exercise.” Trials 18, no. 1 (2017): 20. https://trialsjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s13063-016-1734-1
  5. Higgins, Janine A. “Resistant starch and energy balance: impact on weight loss and maintenance.” Critical reviews in food science and nutrition 54, no. 9 (2014): 1158-1166. http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/10408398.2011.629352
  6. Isaksson, Hanna, Allah Rakha, Roger Andersson, Helena Fredriksson, Johan Olsson, and Per Åman. “Rye kernel breakfast increases satiety in the afternoon-an effect of food structure.” Nutrition journal 10, no. 1 (2011): 31. https://nutritionj.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1475-2891-10-31
  7. Isaksson, Hanna, Birgitta Sundberg, Per Åman, Helena Fredriksson, and Johan Olsson. “Whole grain rye porridge breakfast improves satiety compared to refined wheat bread breakfast.” Food & nutrition research (2008). http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.3402/fnr/v52i0.1809
  8. Isaksson, Hanna, Helena Fredriksson, Roger Andersson, Johan Olsson, and Per Åman. “Effect of rye bread breakfasts on subjective hunger and satiety: a randomized controlled trial.” Nutrition Journal 8, no. 1 (2009): 39. https://nutritionj.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1475-2891-8-39
  9. Johansson, Kari, Johan Sundström, C. Marcus, Erik Hemmingsson, and M. Neovius. “Risk of symptomatic gallstones and cholecystectomy after a very-low-calorie diet or low-calorie diet in a commercial weight loss program: 1-year matched cohort study.” International journal of obesity (2005) 38, no. 2 (2014): 279. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3921672/
  10. Jonnalagadda, Satya S., Lisa Harnack, Rui Hai Liu, Nicola McKeown, Chris Seal, Simin Liu, and George C. Fahey. “Putting the whole grain puzzle together: health benefits associated with whole grains—summary of American Society for Nutrition 2010 Satellite Symposium.” The Journal of nutrition 141, no. 5 (2011): 1011S-1022S. http://jn.nutrition.org/content/141/5/1011S.long
  11. Kallio, Petteri, Marjukka Kolehmainen, David E. Laaksonen, Jani Kekäläinen, Titta Salopuro, Katariina Sivenius, Leena Pulkkinen et al. “Dietary carbohydrate modification induces alterations in gene expression in abdominal subcutaneous adipose tissue in persons with the metabolic syndrome: the FUNGENUT Study.” The American journal of clinical nutrition 85, no. 5 (2007): 1417-1427. http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/85/5/1417.short
  12. Kallio, Petteri, Marjukka Kolehmainen, David E. Laaksonen, Leena Pulkkinen, Mustafa Atalay, Hannu Mykkänen, Matti Uusitupa, Kaisa Poutanen, and Leo Niskanen. “Inflammation markers are modulated by responses to diets differing in postprandial insulin responses in individuals with the metabolic syndrome.” The American journal of clinical nutrition 87, no. 5 (2008): 1497-1503. http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/87/5/1497.short
  13. Kyrø, Cecilie, Anja Olsen, Rikard Landberg, Guri Skeie, Steffen Loft, Per Åman, Max Leenders et al. “Plasma alkylresorcinols, biomarkers of whole-grain wheat and rye intake, and incidence of colorectal cancer.” Journal of the National Cancer Institute 106, no. 1 (2013): djt352. https://academic.oup.com/jnci/article/2517989
  14. Lyon, Michael R., and Veronica Kacinik. “Is there a place for dietary fiber supplements in weight management?.” Current obesity reports 1, no. 2 (2012): 59-67. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13679-012-0016-9
  15. Martínez, Inés, Jaehyoung Kim, Patrick R. Duffy, Vicki L. Schlegel, and Jens Walter. “Resistant starches types 2 and 4 have differential effects on the composition of the fecal microbiota in human subjects.” PloS one 5, no. 11 (2010): e15046. http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0015046
  16. McConnell, T. J., P. N. Appleby, and T. J. Key. “Vegetarian diet as a risk factor for symptomatic gallstone disease.” European Journal of Clinical Nutrition 71, no. 6 (2017): 731-735. https://www.nature.com/ejcn/journal/v71/n6/abs/ejcn2016252a.html
  17. Palidwor et al. (2010) J. Biomed. Discov. Collab. 5, 1-6. Developed by Gareth Palidwor and Miguel Andrade. Hosted at the Ottawa Hospital Research Institute. Powered by Lucene and Google Charts. Consulted on October 2017 at http://mltrends.ogic.ca
  18. Rosén, Liza AH, Lorena O. Blanco Silva, Ulrika K. Andersson, Cecilia Holm, Elin M. Östman, and Inger ME Björck. “Endosperm and whole grain rye breads are characterized by low post-prandial insulin response and a beneficial blood glucose profile.” Nutrition Journal 8, no. 1 (2009): 42. https://nutritionj.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1475-2891-8-42
  19. Saxena, M., and D. R. Modi. “Inflammation and Diabetes.” Interdiscip J Microinflammation 1, no. 110 (2014): 2. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Dr_Madhukar_Saxena/publication/286091524_Inflammation_and_Diabetes/links/56e10b3008ae9b93f79c42ac.pdf
  20. Slavin, Joanne L., Margaret C. Martini, David R. Jacobs, and Len Marquart. “Plausible mechanisms for the protectiveness of whole grains.” The American journal of clinical nutrition 70, no. 3 (1999): 459s-463s. http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/70/3/459s.short
  21. Slavin, Joanne. “Whole grains and human health.” Nutrition research reviews 17, no. 1 (2004): 99-110. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/nutrition-research-reviews/article/whole-grains-and-human-health/D992CF3AF3244A6C85193EBF4557FD2A
  22. Steffensen, Stine K., Hans A. Pedersen, Khem B. Adhikari, Bente B. Laursen, Claudia Jensen, Søren Høyer, Michael Borre et al. “Benzoxazinoids in prostate cancer patients after a rye-intensive diet: methods and initial results.” Journal of agricultural and food chemistry 64, no. 43 (2016): 8235-8245. http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/acs.jafc.6b03765
  23. The Report of the Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee on Dietary Guidelines for Americans. Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services;2005 [cited 2010 Jun 1]. Accessible from: http://www.health.gov/DietaryGuidelines/dga2005/report/.
  24. Vadmerkar, Anuya Anant. “Soluble fiber and resistant starch components in some Indian and Canadian wheat varieties and in a wheat-soy product-Chapati.” (2004). https://theses.lib.vt.edu/theses/available/etd-09152004-155947/unrestricted/ANUYA_MS_THESIS.pdf
  25. Vuholm, Stine, Louise Margrethe Arildsen Jakobsen, Karina Vejrum Sørensen, Ursula Kehlet, Anne Raben, and Mette Kristensen. “Appetite and food intake after consumption of sausages with 10% fat and added wheat or rye bran.” Appetite 73 (2014): 205-211. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0195666313004157
  26. Zhang, Jie-Xian, Göran Hallmans, Herman Adlercreutz, Per Åman, Eric Westerland, Eva Lundin, and Roger Stenling. “Effects of oat rye fractions on biliary and faecal bile acid profiles in Syrian golden hamsters (Mesocricetus auratus).” British Journal of Nutrition 70, no. 2 (1993): 525-536. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/british-journal-of-nutrition/article/effects-of-oat-rye-fractions-on-biliary-and-faecal-bile-acid-profiles-in-syrian-golden-hamsters-mesocricetus-auratus/1182D8180846AFA9C53725170BD31B81
  27. Zhangt, Jie-Xian, Eva Lundin, Carl-Olof Reuterving, Göran Hallmans, Roger Stenling, Eric Westerlund, and Per Åman. “Effects of rye bran, oat bran and soya-bean fibre on bile composition, gallstone formation, gall-bladder morphology and serum cholesterol in Syrian golden hamsters (Mesocricetus auratus).” British journal of nutrition 71, no. 6 (1994): 861-870. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/british-journal-of-nutrition/article/effects-of-rye-bran-oat-bran-and-soya-bean-fibre-on-bile-composition-gallstone-formation-gall-bladder-morphology-and-serum-cholesterol-in-syrian-golden-hamsters-mesocricetus-auratus/091BADFFBCEFE207393186281227FC18
  28. Zhong, Jixin, Quan Gong, and Akira Mima. “Inflammatory Regulation in Diabetes and Metabolic Dysfunction.” Journal of diabetes research 2017 (2017). https://www.jci.org/articles/view/88882
Summary
Is Rye Flour Good For You? A Scientist Explains
Article Name
Is Rye Flour Good For You? A Scientist Explains
Author
Healthy But Smart

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *